[libvirt-users] virDomainGetInfo() returns wrong domain state
Hi Team, I have written below code to get the VM state at run time. I found, though the VM is in shut-off state, when I use the function virDomainGetInfo(); I get state as running. Could you please let me know what wrong I am doing. To know the actual VM state I used 'virsh list' and it clearly shows the VM is in shut-off state. Please find the log and code snippet below. Log from virsh: ================= [host:~]$ virsh list --all Id Name State ---------------------------------------------------- 1 calvados running 2 LCXR running 3 default-sdr--1 running - test--2 shut off Out put: ========= 04.03.06.698923264:INFO: vm_libvirt_state_to_vmm_state: state returned is 1 Note : Here 1 is actually running. Code snippet: =============== enum cidl_vmm_vm_state vm_libvirt_state_to_vmm_state(unsigned char libvirt_state) { enum cidl_vmm_vm_state state; INFO("%s: state returned is %u\n",__FUNCTION__, libvirt_state); <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< if (libvirt_state == VIR_DOMAIN_RUNNING) { state = cidl_vm_state_running; } else if ((libvirt_state == VIR_DOMAIN_PAUSED) || (libvirt_state == VIR_DOMAIN_BLOCKED)) { state = cidl_vm_state_paused; } else if (libvirt_state == VIR_DOMAIN_SHUTOFF) { state = cidl_vm_state_defined; } else { state = cidl_vm_state_not_defined; } return state; } virDomainInfo res_util; virDomainPtr dom = virDomainLookupByName(virt, private_names[vm_idx]); res = virDomainGetInfo(dom, &res_util); vminfo[vm_idx].vm_state = vm_libvirt_state_to_vmm_state(res_util.state); Regards Ritesh Sharma
On 24.09.2013 16:51, Panday Ritesh Sharma (rpanday) wrote:
Hi Team,
I have written below code to get the VM state at run time. I found, though the VM is in shut-off state, when I use the function virDomainGetInfo(); I get state as running. Could you please let me know what wrong I am doing. To know the actual VM state I used ‘virsh list’ and it clearly shows the VM is in shut-off state. Please find the log and code snippet below.
Log from virsh:
=================
[host:~]$ virsh list --all
Id Name State
----------------------------------------------------
1 calvados running
2 LCXR running
3 default-sdr--1 running
- test--2 shut off
Out put:
=========
04.03.06.698923264:INFO: vm_libvirt_state_to_vmm_state: state returned is 1
Note : Here 1 is actually running.
Code snippet:
===============
enum cidl_vmm_vm_state
vm_libvirt_state_to_vmm_state(unsigned char libvirt_state)
{
enum cidl_vmm_vm_state state;
INFO("%s: state returned is %u\n",__FUNCTION__, libvirt_state); <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<
if (libvirt_state == VIR_DOMAIN_RUNNING) {
state = cidl_vm_state_running;
} else if ((libvirt_state == VIR_DOMAIN_PAUSED) ||
(libvirt_state == VIR_DOMAIN_BLOCKED)) {
state = cidl_vm_state_paused;
} else if (libvirt_state == VIR_DOMAIN_SHUTOFF) {
state = cidl_vm_state_defined;
} else {
state = cidl_vm_state_not_defined;
}
return state;
}
While this part ^^^ looks okay, the part below looks suspicious. I mean not from API perspective, but from data perspective.
virDomainInfo res_util;
virDomainPtr dom = virDomainLookupByName(virt,
private_names[vm_idx]);
Are you sure you're passing the correct name here? That's the only possible source of the error here.
res = virDomainGetInfo(dom, &res_util);
vminfo[vm_idx].vm_state =
vm_libvirt_state_to_vmm_state(res_util.state);
Michal
Yes, I am sure because other information pulled are correct. And the same way we have used libvirt APIs to extract other informations at different places. My question is if VM is in shut-off state does it mean running ? IF not, what is the correct state for this VM. I am wondering why the state is 'unsigned char' in virDomainGetInfo, why it could not be 'enum' as it is returning enums only. Regards Ritesh Sharma -----Original Message----- From: Michal Privoznik [mailto:mprivozn@redhat.com] Sent: Thursday, September 26, 2013 12:54 PM To: Panday Ritesh Sharma (rpanday) Cc: libvir-list@redhat.com; libvirt-users@redhat.com; Vinay Shankarkumar (vinays); q-se-dev(mailer list); Basavaraj Bendigeri (bbendige) Subject: Re: [libvirt] virDomainGetInfo() returns wrong domain state On 24.09.2013 16:51, Panday Ritesh Sharma (rpanday) wrote:
Hi Team,
I have written below code to get the VM state at run time. I found, though the VM is in shut-off state, when I use the function virDomainGetInfo(); I get state as running. Could you please let me know what wrong I am doing. To know the actual VM state I used 'virsh list' and it clearly shows the VM is in shut-off state. Please find the log and code snippet below.
Log from virsh:
=================
[host:~]$ virsh list --all
Id Name State
----------------------------------------------------
1 calvados running
2 LCXR running
3 default-sdr--1 running
- test--2 shut off
Out put:
=========
04.03.06.698923264:INFO: vm_libvirt_state_to_vmm_state: state returned is 1
Note : Here 1 is actually running.
Code snippet:
===============
enum cidl_vmm_vm_state
vm_libvirt_state_to_vmm_state(unsigned char libvirt_state)
{
enum cidl_vmm_vm_state state;
INFO("%s: state returned is %u\n",__FUNCTION__, libvirt_state); <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<
if (libvirt_state == VIR_DOMAIN_RUNNING) {
state = cidl_vm_state_running;
} else if ((libvirt_state == VIR_DOMAIN_PAUSED) ||
(libvirt_state == VIR_DOMAIN_BLOCKED)) {
state = cidl_vm_state_paused;
} else if (libvirt_state == VIR_DOMAIN_SHUTOFF) {
state = cidl_vm_state_defined;
} else {
state = cidl_vm_state_not_defined;
}
return state;
}
While this part ^^^ looks okay, the part below looks suspicious. I mean not from API perspective, but from data perspective.
virDomainInfo res_util;
virDomainPtr dom = virDomainLookupByName(virt,
private_names[vm_idx]);
Are you sure you're passing the correct name here? That's the only possible source of the error here.
res = virDomainGetInfo(dom, &res_util);
vminfo[vm_idx].vm_state =
vm_libvirt_state_to_vmm_state(res_util.state);
Michal
On 26.09.2013 11:48, Panday Ritesh Sharma (rpanday) wrote:
Yes, I am sure because other information pulled are correct. And the same way we have used libvirt APIs to extract other informations at different places.
My question is if VM is in shut-off state does it mean running ? IF not, what is the correct state for this VM. I am wondering why the state is 'unsigned char' in virDomainGetInfo, why it could not be 'enum' as it is returning enums only.
Domain in the shut-off state is shut off. It is not running. The state is unsigned char due to ABI stability. If it were enum and we add a new item into the enum we can hardly avoid breaking ABI. In general, compiler may decide more space is needed to store the enum and hence the ABI won't be compatible. That is, after you've upgraded the libvirt, you'll get malicious errors even though your code is just correct. Michal
participants (2)
-
Michal Privoznik -
Panday Ritesh Sharma (rpanday)