I was wondering if any of these patches actually made it into libvirt code. I'm really looking forward hyper-v support improvement and features like shutdown VM (not destroy/turn off but clean shutdown) implemented. Especially interested in 2012/2012 R2 since 2008 is getting old and 2016 is right around the corner.

Hi, > I was wondering if any of these patches actually made it into > libvirt code. > I'm really looking forward hyper-v support improvement and features > like shutdown VM (not destroy/turn off but clean shutdown) > implemented. > Especially interested in 2012/2012 R2 since 2008 is getting old and > 2016 is right around the corner. Unfortunately they have not made it in or received enough of a review (yet) -- my guess is that this is because Hyper-V hosts/clusters are not wide spread and devs cannot test the patches. @libvirt-devs, if that is the case, we (Datto) would be happy to provide test servers for you so you can play around with the patches. Just contact me or Jason M (see previous mails) directly and we'll talk about it. We are also working on additional patches to provide a more extensive support. The patches that Jason submitted are just the beginning and provide very basic support. Best, Phil

2016-09-07 23:14 GMT+02:00 Fernando Casas Schössow < casasfernando(a)hotmail.com&gt;: > Hi there, > > I was wondering if any of these patches actually made it into libvirt code. > I'm really looking forward hyper-v support improvement and features like > shutdown VM (not destroy/turn off but clean shutdown) implemented. > Especially interested in 2012/2012 R2 since 2008 is getting old and 2016 is > right around the corner. > > I'm already using libvirt 2.1.0 with some patches I found in > https://github.com/vikhyath/libvirt-hyperv-r2-2012 but it would be great to > have the code reviewed and merged into libvirt releases. > > Thanks. > > Fer > > The following patches include work originally done by Yves Vinter back > in 2014. The last patch introduces support for Hyper-V 2012, while still > supporting 2008. I am not sure that the method I used to include the 2012 > support is the best approach, mainly due to code duplication, but I am > open to suggestions on how to do this better. > > Jason Miesionczek (16): > hyperv: additional server 2008 wmi classes > hyperv: add cim types support to code generator > hyperv: add get capabilities > hyperv: implement connectGetVersion > hyperv: implement vcpu functions > hyperv: implement nodeGetFreeMemory > hyperv: implement ability to send xml soap requests > hyperv: introduce basic network driver > hyperv: add domain shutdown function > hyperv: add get scheduler functions > hyperv: add set memory functions > hyperv: set vpcu functions > hyperv: domain undefine functions > hyperv: domain define and associated functions > hyperv: network list functions > hyperv: introduce 2012 support I had a quick look at these patches a while ago, but didn't get around to review them in detail yet. Adding 2012 support while keeping 2008 supported is a bit tricky but doable I think. -- Matthias Bolte http://photron.blogspot.com -- libvir-list mailing list libvir-list(a)redhat.com https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/libvir-list

Hi Phil, May I ask which libvirt version are you patching against? I'm trying to apply this patches to libvirt 2.2.0 but some of them are failing (for example patch 7). Thanks. Fer On jue, sep 8, 2016 at 12:28 , Philipp Heckel <pheckel(a)datto.com&gt; wrote: > We have a lot more implemented, but they're not cleaned up yet or > properly tested. We'll submit them in the following weeks (ideally > next week). > > Again, if you need test infrastructure, contact me or Jason. > > Here's what we have so far: > > 2012 > ---- > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectGetCapabilities = > hypervConnectGetCapabilities; /* 2008 & 2012 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectGetHostname = > hypervConnectGetHostname; /* 2008 & 2012 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectGetType = hypervConnectGetType; /* > 2008 & 2012 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectIsAlive = hypervConnectIsAlive; /* > 2008 & 2012 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectListAllDomains = > hypervConnectListAllDomains2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectListDefinedDomains = > hypervConnectListDefinedDomains2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectListDomains = > hypervConnectListDomains2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectNumOfDefinedDomains = > hypervConnectNumOfDefinedDomains2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectNumOfDomains = > hypervConnectNumOfDomains2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainCreate = hypervDomainCreate2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainCreateWithFlags = > hypervDomainCreateWithFlags2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainDefineXML = hypervDomainDefineXML2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainDestroyFlags = > hypervDomainDestroyFlags2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainDestroy = hypervDomainDestroy2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainGetInfo = hypervDomainGetInfo2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainGetState = hypervDomainGetState2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainGetXMLDesc = hypervDomainGetXMLDesc2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainIsActive = hypervDomainIsActive2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainLookupByID = hypervDomainLookupByID2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainLookupByName = > hypervDomainLookupByName2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainLookupByUUID = > hypervDomainLookupByUUID2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainReboot = hypervDomainReboot2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainSendKey = hypervDomainSendKey2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainSetMemoryFlags = > hypervDomainSetMemoryFlags2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainSetMemory = hypervDomainSetMemory2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainShutdownFlags = > hypervDomainShutdownFlags2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainShutdown = hypervDomainShutdown2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainUndefineFlags = > hypervDomainUndefineFlags2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainUndefine = hypervDomainUndefine2012; > hypervHypervisorDriver.nodeGetFreeMemory = hypervNodeGetFreeMemory; > /* 2008 & 2012 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.nodeGetInfo = hypervNodeGetInfo; /* 2008 & > 2012 */ > > 2008 > ---- > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectGetCapabilities = > hypervConnectGetCapabilities; /* 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectGetHostname = > hypervConnectGetHostname; /* 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectGetMaxVcpus = > hypervConnectGetMaxVcpus; /* 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectGetType = hypervConnectGetType; /* > 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectGetVersion = hypervConnectGetVersion; > /* 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectIsAlive = hypervConnectIsAlive; /* > 0.9.8 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectIsEncrypted = > hypervConnectIsEncrypted; /* 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectIsSecure = hypervConnectIsSecure; /* > 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectListAllDomains = > hypervConnectListAllDomains; /* 0.10.2 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectListDefinedDomains = > hypervConnectListDefinedDomains; /* 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectListDomains = > hypervConnectListDomains; /* 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectNumOfDefinedDomains = > hypervConnectNumOfDefinedDomains; /* 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.connectNumOfDomains = > hypervConnectNumOfDomains; /* 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainAttachDeviceFlags = > hypervDomainAttachDeviceFlags; /* 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainAttachDevice = > hypervDomainAttachDevice; /* 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainCreate = hypervDomainCreate; /* 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainCreateWithFlags = > hypervDomainCreateWithFlags; /* 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainCreateXML = hypervDomainCreateXML; /* > 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainDefineXML = hypervDomainDefineXML; /* > 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainDestroyFlags = > hypervDomainDestroyFlags; /* 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainDestroy = hypervDomainDestroy; /* 0.9.5 > */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainGetAutostart = > hypervDomainGetAutostart; /* 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainGetInfo = hypervDomainGetInfo; /* 0.9.5 > */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainGetMaxVcpus = hypervDomainGetMaxVcpus; > /* 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainGetOSType = hypervDomainGetOSType; /* > 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainGetSchedulerParametersFlags = > hypervDomainGetSchedulerParametersFlags; /* 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainGetSchedulerParameters = > hypervDomainGetSchedulerParameters; /* 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainGetSchedulerType = > hypervDomainGetSchedulerType; /* 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainGetState = hypervDomainGetState; /* > 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainGetVcpusFlags = > hypervDomainGetVcpusFlags; /* 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainGetVcpus = hypervDomainGetVcpus; /* > 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainGetXMLDesc = hypervDomainGetXMLDesc; /* > 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainHasManagedSaveImage = > hypervDomainHasManagedSaveImage; /* 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainIsActive = hypervDomainIsActive; /* > 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainIsPersistent = > hypervDomainIsPersistent; /* 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainIsUpdated = hypervDomainIsUpdated; /* > 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainLookupByID = hypervDomainLookupByID; /* > 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainLookupByName = > hypervDomainLookupByName; /* 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainLookupByUUID = > hypervDomainLookupByUUID; /* 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainManagedSave = hypervDomainManagedSave; > /* 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainManagedSaveRemove = > hypervDomainManagedSaveRemove; /* 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainReboot = hypervDomainReboot; /* 1.3.x */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainResume = hypervDomainResume; /* 0.9.5 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainScreenshot = hypervDomainScreenshot; /* > pjr - 08/08/16 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainSendKey = hypervDomainSendKey; /* 1.3.x > */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainSetAutostart = > hypervDomainSetAutostart; /* 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainSetMaxMemory = > hypervDomainSetMaxMemory; /* 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainSetMemoryFlags = > hypervDomainSetMemoryFlags; /* 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainSetMemory = hypervDomainSetMemory; /* > 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainSetVcpusFlags = > hypervDomainSetVcpusFlags; /* 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainSetVcpus = hypervDomainSetVcpus; /* > 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainShutdownFlags = > hypervDomainShutdownFlags; /* 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainShutdown = hypervDomainShutdown; /* > 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainSuspend = hypervDomainSuspend; /* 0.9.5 > */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainUndefineFlags = > hypervDomainUndefineFlags; /* 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.domainUndefine = hypervDomainUndefine; /* > 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.nodeGetFreeMemory = hypervNodeGetFreeMemory; > /* 1.2.10 */ > hypervHypervisorDriver.nodeGetInfo = hypervNodeGetInfo; /* 0.9.5 */ > > > On Wed, Sep 7, 2016 at 6:17 PM, Matthias Bolte > <matthias.bolte(a)googlemail.com&gt; wrote: >> 2016-09-07 23:14 GMT+02:00 Fernando Casas Schössow >> <casasfernando(a)hotmail.com&gt;: >> > Hi there, >> > >> > I was wondering if any of these patches actually made it into >> libvirt code. >> > I'm really looking forward hyper-v support improvement and >> features like >> > shutdown VM (not destroy/turn off but clean shutdown) implemented. >> > Especially interested in 2012/2012 R2 since 2008 is getting old >> and 2016 is >> > right around the corner. >> > >> > I'm already using libvirt 2.1.0 with some patches I found in >> > https://github.com/vikhyath/libvirt-hyperv-r2-2012 but it would >> be great to >> > have the code reviewed and merged into libvirt releases. >> > >> > Thanks. >> > >> > Fer >> > >> > The following patches include work originally done by Yves Vinter >> back >> > in 2014. The last patch introduces support for Hyper-V 2012, >> while still >> > supporting 2008. I am not sure that the method I used to include >> the 2012 >> > support is the best approach, mainly due to code duplication, but >> I am >> > open to suggestions on how to do this better. >> > >> > Jason Miesionczek (16): >> > hyperv: additional server 2008 wmi classes >> > hyperv: add cim types support to code generator >> > hyperv: add get capabilities >> > hyperv: implement connectGetVersion >> > hyperv: implement vcpu functions >> > hyperv: implement nodeGetFreeMemory >> > hyperv: implement ability to send xml soap requests >> > hyperv: introduce basic network driver >> > hyperv: add domain shutdown function >> > hyperv: add get scheduler functions >> > hyperv: add set memory functions >> > hyperv: set vpcu functions >> > hyperv: domain undefine functions >> > hyperv: domain define and associated functions >> > hyperv: network list functions >> > hyperv: introduce 2012 support >> >> I had a quick look at these patches a while ago, but didn't get >> around >> to review them in detail yet. >> >> Adding 2012 support while keeping 2008 supported is a bit tricky but >> doable I think. >> >> -- >> Matthias Bolte >> http://photron.blogspot.com >> >> -- >> libvir-list mailing list >> libvir-list(a)redhat.com >> https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/libvir-list > > > > -- > Philipp Heckel > Principal Engineer & Team Lead > Datto, Inc. > +1-475-288-1277 > www.datto.com > > > Join the conversation!