Re: [libvirt] [RFC] Accepting PRs/MRs for libvirt on GitHub/GitLab

First of all, we'd remove the ominous message from GitHub mirror repositories (interestingly, the same is not present on GitLab).

Then, we'd starting accepting PRs/MRs. The way we'd handle them is that, when one comes in, one among the handful of core developers who volunteered to do so would review the patches on the respective platform, working with the submitter to get it into shape just like they would do on the mailing list; once the series is finally ready to be merged, the core developer would update the PR/MR as necessary, for example picking up R-bs or fixing the kind of trivial issues that usually don't warrant a repost, and then push to master as usual. More in detail: GitHub and GitLab have a feature that allows project members to update PRs/MRs: basically the way it works is that, if the PR/MR was created by the user 'foo' from their branch 'bar', the libvirt developer is allowed to (force-)push to the foo/libvirt/bar branch, and doing so updates the corresponding PR/MR; after that, if the updated branch is locally merged into master and master is pushed to the libvirt.org repo, once it gets mirrored GitHub/GitLab will recognize that the commit IDs match and automatically mark the PR/MR as merged. I have tested this behavior on both platforms (minus the mirroring part) with Martin's help. One last important bit. In the spirit of not requiring core developers to alter their workflow, the developer who reviewed the patches on GitHub/GitLab will also be responsible to format them to the mailing list after merging them: this way, even those who don't have a GitHub/GitLab account will get a chance to take notice of the code changes and weigh in. Unlike what we're used to, this feedback will come after the fact, but assuming that issues are spotted only at that point we can either push the relevant fixes as follow-up commits or even revert the series outright, so I don't feel like it would be a massive problem overall.

Thoughts? [1] https://github.com/libvirt/libvirt/pulls?q=is:pr+is:closed -- Andrea Bolognani / Red Hat / Virtualization -- libvir-list mailing list libvir-list(a)redhat.com https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/libvir-list